On behalf of journalist Yoav Gonen and The City Report, Inc., publisher of THE CITY, the Clinic filed this Freedom of Information Law (FOIL) lawsuit against the New York City Police Department. Gonen filed three FOIL requests for records with NYPD that the Department unlawfully denied, and this lawsuit seeks to obtain those records to help the public understand NYPD’s actions.

The facts underlying these FOIL requests are simple. Samuel Williams died in May 2023 after a collision with an unmarked NYPD vehicle. Body-worn camera footage released by the New York Attorney General shows that an NYPD officer crossed into oncoming traffic with his unmarked vehicle and hit Williams head-on. With the critically injured Williams splayed on the hood of the NYPD vehicle, a broken leg bone reportedly jutting through his pants, officers put him in handcuffs before attempting to help him. He died at a hospital the next day.

Gonen, a journalist who covers the NYPD, filed FOIL requests seeking body-worn camera footage, other recordings obtained by NYPD, and the closing memo issued by the Department’s Force Investigation Division. These records would reveal the actions of NYPD officers and the extent to which the Department investigated its officers’ actions.

NYPD denied the requests. It claimed that all responsive records were “sealed under court order, pursuant to Criminal Procedure Law Section 160.50.” That law requires certain records to be sealed after a prosecution is terminated in favor of the defendant in specified circumstances. It is intended to make sure that acquitted defendants don’t suffer stigma as a result of being charged with a crime that they were not convicted of.

Williams had not been charged with any crime before he died, nor do his circumstances meet any of the other preconditions necessary for Section 160.50 to apply. Additionally, the records that Gonen seeks — some of which have already been released by the Attorney General — would not be shielded by Section 160.50 even if the statute did apply in Williams’ circumstance. 

This lawsuit seeks to obtain the public records that Gonen requested, which cannot properly be shielded from the public. The law does not allow NYPD to hide the actions of its own officers that caused the death of a man who was never charged with a crime.

Information on this page is provided for archival purposes. All newly created PDFs on this website are accessible. For an accommodation for PDFs on this page, please contact law-web-ada@cornell.edu.